✨ New Arrivals Just Dropped!Explore

Home Shop Cart Account

Top Rated Gifts

Top Rated Gifts

Price

Min

-

Max

Collections

All ProductsBrandsAll Gift SetsBaking MixesBaking Mixes2023 Gift GuideBakery & CandyBaking Mixes & BattersAll Things PumpkinAll American Summer CollectionAll Things PecanBaking GiftsAn Old Mill ChristmasJamChow-ChowApple-achianJams, Jellies, & SpreadsPantry FavoritesBakewareFather's Day

The Old Mill Shop Online

Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive offers, new arrivals, and style inspiration.

Shop

All Products
New Arrivals
Sale

Company

Shipping Info
FAQ
Contact Us

About

About Us
Returns
Privacy

© 2026 The Old Mill Shop Online. All rights reserved.

-70%NEW

Soup Sampler

$34.99

$10.50

NEW

Soup Mug Gift Set

$88.99

NEW

Chowder And Cornbread Sampler

$28.99

NEW

The Old Mill Restaurant Sampler

$99.99

-70%NEW

The Old Mill Restaurant Pecan Pie

$39.99

$12.00

NEW

The Pottery House Cafe Chocolate Pecan Pie

$39.99

-70%NEW

Brittle Sampler Gift Set

$39.99

$12.00

NEW

Breakfast at the Old Mill

$79.99

-70%NEW

Pie Plate Gift Set

$99.99

$30.00

-70%NEW

Taffy Gift Box

$14.99

$4.50

-70%NEW

Bread Baker Gift Set

$109.99

$33.00